Donald Trump is currently in a hell of his own making. For years, he amplified conspiracy theories about pedophile sex trafficker Jeffrey Epstein. Now that he's back in the White House, he's denying and downplaying the story. He wants his followers to "move on." But that won't work. The simple reason: the Epstein story has already been framed in the minds of the MAGA masses. This means Trump's new claims will bounce right off of their brains and, potentially, make them see Trump as a betrayer of trust. For years, Trump positioned himself as the hero of a very specific story: the Crusader against the Deep State, the Truth-Teller who would expose corruption, the Outsider fighting a rigged system. At the center of this heroic narrative sat the mythical Epstein Client List. It wasn't just a document, but a sacred object in the MAGA cosmology—the promised revelation that would vindicate every conspiracy theory and expose every enemy. Trump positioned himself as the keeper of this holy grail of right-wing conspiracy theories. He sold himself as the only leader brave enough to reveal its contents. But now Trump is trying to flip the script. His administration says there's no Epstein Client List. Attorney General Pam Bondi, who once said it was sitting on her desk, now denies its existence entirely. That's not just a policy reversal. It's a catastrophic frame collapse, and one that appears to seriously jeopardize Trump. His poll numbers are falling and a majority of Americans—Democrats and Republicans alike—believe he's hiding something. His usual tactics, like blaming Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama, are falling flat. To be clear, Trump's base continues to support him, but there are signs of fracture. "The base is about evenly split on the administration's actions, meaning there's a higher degree of skepticism than we almost ever see with Trump," reports CNN. "And that might actually undersell the level of lingering GOP concern." Trump's followers didn't just want the Epstein files for partisan advantage. They wanted them as proof that their entire worldview was correct. When Trump asks them to "move on" from the files, he's asking them to abandon a key frame that made him their hero. Brains don't work that way. When faced with information that contradicts our deepest organizing principles, we tend to reject the contradictory information entirely. The MAGA adherents who bought into Trump's Epstein conspiracies can't turn back now. The contradiction is too stark, too public, too undeniable. With his flip-flop on Epstein, Trump is reframing himself. The hero frame is collapsing into what we might call a Betrayer frame. Suddenly, Trump's extremely close relationship with Epstein—previously explained away or ignored—may become the central organizing principle of a new story. The hero who promised to expose the conspiracy becomes the conspirator himself. The outsider fighting the system reveals himself as the ultimate insider. The Cognitive Architecture of ConspiracyThis reveals something about how conspiracy theories work. Once a population has been trained to think in conspiratorial terms—to assume hidden forces, secret cabals, and elaborate deceptions—those thinking patterns don't disappear when the original conspiracy proves false. Trump taught his followers that they live in a world of lies and deception, where nothing is as it seems and powerful people are always hiding the truth. That frame doesn't dissolve when Trump himself becomes the liar. It adapts. The very cognitive tools Trump gave his followers to distrust the "Deep State" are now being turned on Trump himself. He created a narrative structure where heroic truth-tellers battle corrupt deceivers, never imagining he might end up cast as the deceiver. The Betrayer frame is psychologically satisfying in the same way the original hero frame was. It provides a simple, coherent explanation for complex events. It validates the conspiratorial thinking patterns Trump taught his followers. It just casts Trump as the villain instead of the hero. Why did Trump fill his first administration with Goldman Sachs executives? Because he was never really the outsider. Why did he fail to "drain the swamp"? Because he was always part of it. Why won't he release the Epstein files? Because, as former Trump administration official Elon Musk has said, his name is in them. The Broader Threat to DemocracyThis dynamic reveals the deeper threat posed by conspiratorial thinking. Democracy depends on citizens' ability to distinguish between reliable and unreliable information, to update their beliefs based on evidence, and to hold leaders accountable for their promises. But conspiracy theories make this kind of democratic reasoning impossible. When your brain operates on the assumption that everything is a lie and everyone is hiding something, evidence becomes meaningless. Truth becomes whatever fits the deranged narrative. Trump's MAGA movement now faces a profound cognitive crisis. Their leader has violated the central promise of their political identity—the promise to reveal hidden truths and expose child sex abusers. But the conspiratorial frame he taught them makes it impossible to simply accept this as ordinary political disappointment. Instead, they must choose between two equally destabilizing options: abandon the conspiratorial thinking that has become central to their identity, or turn that conspiratorial thinking against Trump himself. We're seeing the consequences of this on social media, in polls and in MAGA circles right now. Some of Trump's biggest supporters are openly criticizing him. And some of his followers have even taken to publicly burning their signature red MAGA hats. "Donald Trump's efforts to dismiss the criticism over his administration's handling of the Jeffrey Epstein files as a 'hoax' showed no sign of working on Thursday as more prominent figures from across the political spectrum emerged to attack the US president and some of his supporters recorded videos burning their signature Make America Great Again hats," the Guardian reported on July 17. They feel betrayed—because they have been betrayed, on the deepest level imaginable. The betrayal isn't just that Trump is hiding the Epstein files. The betrayal is that he trained them to think in ways that make them perpetual victims of whoever can craft the most compelling conspiracy fiction. This is why fighting conspiracy theories with facts doesn't work. Facts are interpreted through frames, and frames shape how facts are understood. When someone is thinking conspiratorially, contradictory evidence just becomes proof of how deep the conspiracy goes. The Betrayer frame may feel satisfying to Trump's former followers, but it's just another conspiracy theory—another simple story imposed on complex reality. Democracy can't survive in a society where significant numbers of people have lost the ability to distinguish between evidence and narrative, between facts and frames, between truth and the stories we tell ourselves about truth. The question now is whether democratic institutions can adapt faster than authoritarian ones can exploit the cognitive vulnerabilities that conspiracy thinking creates. The Epstein files may hasten Trump's downfall with his base. But the conspiratorial thinking he unleashed will outlast him—unless we learn to recognize it and counter it with better ways of understanding the world. In the meantime, Trump is now at his most dangerous. Cornered and dropping in popularity, he desperately needs to change the narrative and regain his footing. This means he must create new crises and storylines to distract from his failure and betrayal. Already, we're seeing the makings of his next moves. Attorney General Bondi has announced that the Department of Justice will interview Ghislaine Maxwell, the Epstein partner currently serving 20 years in prison for child sex trafficking and other offenses. But a few weeks ago, Bondi claimed Maxwell had no useful information to offer. "The Trump administration is struggling to escape the conspiracy vortex that its own leaders spent years fomenting," reports Politico. "And now they're casting about for ways to show the MAGA base that they're pursuing new evidence in the Epstein case — even though they've already concluded there's nothing new to learn and said so just two weeks ago." The purpose seems transparent: pressure Maxwell to craft a new narrative, likely one that absolves Trump and blames Democrats. Trump also made headlines by attacking former President Barack Obama and fantasizing about throwing him in jail. Trump's Authoritarian PlaybookThis is the authoritarian playbook in action. When one lie collapses, create a bigger lie. When your base feels betrayed, give them a new enemy to hate. The Epstein reversal may have shattered Trump's hero frame, but he's betting he can rebuild it by casting himself as the victim of an even deeper conspiracy. The question is whether his followers will buy it, or whether they've finally learned to recognize the pattern. Either way, democracy hangs in the balance. Because a would-be authoritarian who has lost the trust of his base will do anything to get it back. Further reading: What Can We Do?Beware the new lies. When Trump rolls out his next Epstein conspiracy, don't debunk it point by point—that spreads their narrative. Focus on the pattern: he creates new lies to cover old lies. Help others see the cycle. Share this framework with people who might fall for Trump's next conspiracy. The Maxwell interview is desperation, not investigation. Stay focused on what's real. Trump wants you chasing conspiracies—believing them or debunking them. Either way, you're playing his game. Focus on actual threats: voter suppression, corruption, abuse of power. | 
Posts
